Key Takeaways

  • Most Brooklyn car accident lawyers work on a contingency fee, so the client pays no attorney fee unless the case recovers money.
  • New York court rules cap how much a lawyer can take from a personal injury recovery.
  • Case expenses are separate from the attorney fee, and an initial consultation is typically free.

Many clients pay a Brooklyn car accident lawyer through a contingency fee, which is a percentage of the recovery collected only if the case wins. New York court rules cap that percentage, and most firms charge one-third. Case expenses are separate from the attorney fee and are usually repaid from the settlement. When a car accident case loses, the client typically owes no fee at all.

How Does a Contingency Fee Work in New York?

A contingency fee in New York personal injury cases pays the lawyer a set share of any recovery, but only if the case succeeds. A written retainer agreement sets that percentage before work begins. The lawyer must then file a retainer statement with the OCA (Office of Court Administration) within 30 days. After a settlement or Kings County Supreme Court verdict, the lawyer files a closing statement showing how the money was allocated.

What Percentage Do Car Accident Lawyers Take in Brooklyn?

Most car accident lawyers in Brooklyn take one-third of the recovery, the highest flat rate New York court rules allow. The rules also permit a sliding scale that starts at 50% of the first $1,000 and falls to 25% above $25,000. Since those caps apply statewide, car accident lawyer fees in New York look similar from firm to firm.

What Is the Difference Between Attorney Fees and Case Expenses?

Attorney fees pay for the lawyer’s time and skill, whereas case expenses cover the costs of building the claim. Typical expenses include court filing fees, police reports, medical records, deposition transcripts, and testimony from doctors or other paid witnesses. Filing a lawsuit in Kings County, for example, starts with a $210 index number fee paid to the County Clerk. Some lawyers advance these costs while the case is open.

Do I Pay a Lawyer if I Lose?

In most cases, a client owes no attorney fee if the case does not win. Case expenses, however, can work differently. Some agreements forgive advanced costs after a loss, whereas others require the client to repay them. A Brooklyn car accident lawyer should explain that in detail before the client signs.

Is Hiring a Lawyer Worth the Fee?

With NYC DOT (New York City Department of Transportation) data showing 10,789 drivers and passengers injured in Brooklyn crashes in 2024, insurers face heavy claim volume and often open low. Hiring a lawyer often pays off when injuries are serious or fault is disputed.  Anyone weighing how much does a car accident lawyer cost in Brooklyn should measure the fee against that gain.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the first consultation free?

Many Brooklyn injury firms offer a free first consultation to review the facts and explain the fee agreement.

Do I pay upfront?

A contingency case requires no retainer deposit or hourly billing at the start.

Are fees taken before or after expenses?

New York requires fees to be figured on the net recovery, which is the amount left after expenses. A one-third fee on a $30,000 settlement with $3,000 in costs equals $9,000.

Can I change lawyers mid-case?

A client can switch lawyers at any point, and the firms usually split a single fee based on the work each one performed.

Brooklyn Car Accident Lawyers at Rubenstein & Rynecki Charge No Fee Unless We Win

If you have been in a motor vehicle collision, reach out to the Brooklyn car accident lawyers at Rubenstein & Rynecki. Our trusted legal team will provide honest answers about our fee schedule. Call us at 718-522-1020 or complete the online contact form for a free consultation. With offices located in Brooklyn, we proudly serve all clients throughout New York City.